1966
"bits of paper tape w vith electronic drawings on them generated by the sounds of the concert."
In his September 14, 1966, review “Avant-Garde Music Switched on Here,” New York Times critic Theodore Strongin provides a skeptical and somewhat bewildered account of the 4th Annual New York Avant-Garde Festival.
While the festival featured a variety of experimental artists, Strongin’s commentary on Max Neuhaus highlights a fundamental clash between traditional music criticism and the emerging field of sound art: Process vs. Product: Strongin critiqued Neuhaus’s work (specifically referencing the piece Bi-Product) for focusing too heavily on the mechanical or conceptual process rather than the final musical result. Rejection of the Concert Format: The review notes Strongin's resistance to the "happening" style of the event. He argued that a concert should focus on musical composition, whereas the avant-garde’s blurring of disciplines into performance art was, in his view, a departure from artistic standards. Technological Skepticism: Strongin expressed concern that the electronic and computer-generated elements—frequent in Neuhaus's collaborations at the time—threatened to dehumanize music and remove the importance of the live performer